Merchant Account Types
Merchant Account Providers
News & Advice
Merchant Account Tools
Chargebacks: Yes, merchants have rights
Chargebacks. It's almost as though merchants are guilty until proven innocent. That's how one expert describes the reasoning behind strongly pro-consumer policies that protect credit card users against fraud. But merchants have rights, too, as well as a few ways to protect themselves from unsubstantiated chargebacks.
When a cardholder claims that a credit card transaction was unauthorized, the dispute is handled through a chargeback, in which the card issuer electronically refunds a charge to the card holder. The dollar amount of the original sale -- plus a fee ranging from $20 to $100 per transaction -- is deducted from the merchant's funds.
Chargebacks are designed to help consumers resolve fraudulent transactions if their efforts to resolve the issue with merchants are fruitless. But some card holders take advantage of the chargeback process. For example, they might make a legitimate transaction and receive a product but later claim they did not make the transaction or fabricate a problem with it and go directly to their card-issuing bank to get an automatic refund. This is known as "friendly fraud" and it puts the burden of proof on the merchant to show that a charge was authorized by the card holder.
"The bank is a shortcut, but chargebacks were invented as a last-resort solution rather than a first-resort solution," says Monica Eaton-Cardone, cofounder and chief operating officer of Chargebacks911, a company that helps merchants prevent and fight chargebacks and provides comprehensive risk service management.
Friendly fraud is a real and costly problem for merchants. In 2013, chargeback fraud was a $40 billion problem, according to a recent article Eaton-Cardone wrote for Transaction World Magazine. And Verifi cites a LexisNexis report estimating that merchants incur a $279 loss for every $100 in fraud losses because of the cost of distracting staff from their regular work, plus fees and even penalties if chargebacks become frequent. Only 14 percent of card holders who filed a chargeback dispute had contacted the merchant about resolving the issue first, according to a white paper by the global electronic payment and risk management solutions company Verifi. The company's study shows that 28 percent of those card holders contacted the merchant only after filing a dispute, and 58 percent did not contact the merchant at all.
"There are many reasons consumers engage in friendly fraud -- some use chargebacks as a form of shoplifting, others claim they never received goods or services because of buyer's remorse," the white paper says.
Eaton-Cardone said that many merchants do not realize they can fight chargebacks by submitting a case to a card issuer to win back the transaction value. It's also important to know that chargeback fees are not reimbursed, regardless of whether the chargeback stands or is successfully disputed. Essentially, a merchant pays for the time a credit card company spends investigating the chargeback.
According to Verifi, solid documentation about a transaction can strengthen a merchant's odds of winning a chargeback dispute. Merchants have the right to retain customer information for this purpose, and it's up to a merchant to fight back in order to protect its bottom line. So Verifi recommends merchants take measures to prevent chargebacks and aggressively work to recover these lost funds. Acceptable proof of a transaction includes:
Once this information is submitted, each credit card company might have its own process, but Sanette Chao, director of corporate affairs for American Express, outlined that company's charge dispute process:
Resolving these disputes can take time, so the best approach is to try to avoid them altogether. Eaton-Cardone offers this advice to merchants who want to prevent chargebacks:
Published: July 24,2022